Monday, August 16, 2010

The Academy Responds

Esteemed film critic Leo Braudy, the leading voice of the status quo and professor at the University of Southern California, has generously responded via email to the announcement of this new blog. As to be expected, he disagrees with ELP’s bold proclamation.

********************************

Leo Braudy:

Sorry to be negative, but for all its lavish production El Cid is to me a very boring film, slavishly hieratic and bound to some strange repetition of the static speechifying of Corneille's original. It comes alive only briefly towards the end, and seems otherwise entirely bereft of the well-staged action and psychological subtexts that mark so many of Mann's other works. As in his next film, The Fall of the Roman Empire, some potentially interesting touches are submerged in a choking preoccupation with sets, costumes, etc.

********************************* 

I thank Professor Braudy for his response. I wonder: Are we talking about the same movie? I saw “El Cid” scarcely one month ago on a large movie screen in New York. I found “El Cid” to be thrilling and unsettling. The experience of viewing it as it was meant to be viewed was overwhelming. I was on the edge of my seat throughout. Most of all, I was stunned by the depth of the film’s themes, and by the extent of relevance to the world we live in now.

The academy produces and supports not originality, but competence. Professor Braudy gives his personal opinion, but it also happens to be received wisdom. His voice about “El Cid” is the accepted voice. I’d wager his other judgments would similarly fall down the line of what’s long been valued and revered in film studies. Does Professor Braudy highly rate “Citizen Kane”? It’s no surprise to find after some quick googling that he does.

Maybe his opinion is the objective reality. Maybe “Citizen Kane” is “the best,” as Braudy assesses it. Maybe “El Cid” is in fact not very good.

To counter this I present the opinion of film buffs, as expressed at

www.imdb.com/title/tt0054847/usercomments

Is IMDB the opinion of the mob? Not quite. The mob is watching “Step Up 3D” at the cinemaplex. But IMDB is not expert opinion, as Braudy’s is expert opinion. Leo Braudy has spent his life becoming, and being, the expert. His degrees, position, and standing prove it.

Much of what Braudy says is answered by the Arguments I’ve already made for “El Cid,” found linked on the right of this blog. Please click them on. I’ll make a few more comments in a few short posts to come.

“El Cid” is objectively a greater, stronger, and deeper movie than “Citizen Kane.” This will be shown.

Saturday, August 14, 2010

The Natural World

THE BIG INNOVATION of American film in the 1950s wasn't just the wide screen and more prevalent use of gorgeous Technicolor. Moviemakers went on location-- outdoors, into the natural world. This resulted in some of the most beautiful, eye-pleasing movies ever made. One of them is "El Cid."

Wednesday, August 11, 2010

The Power of Art

The Ground Zero mosque crisis can be resolved through art—through the emotional force of viewing great art. All parties involved should view “El Cid” as it was meant to be seen, on a movie screen. The film depicts what everyone wants: the coming together of Christians and moderate Muslims, and the defeat of radical Islam. This is what all sides in the controversy say they want. Will they support “El Cid”?

Get everyone into a movie theater, Imam Rauf, Mayor Bloomberg, and Sarah Palin alike, and it will be a cathartic experience. 

Friday, August 6, 2010

The Neglected Movie

Why has “El Cid,” the ultimate motion picture experience (when seen as a motion picture) been so irrationally ignored by film critics? It finds no spot on various “Best 1,000” movie lists, for all its visual and aural splendor, its overwhelming artistic and thematic power.

What about the film “El Cid” isn’t acceptable?

Its lead actor? (Charlton Heston.)

Its theme of courage and honor?

Its Christian vs radical Muslim plot?

Inquiring minds want to know.

Character, Honor, Courage

The two lead characters in "El Cid," Rodrigo and Chimene, played by Charlton Heston and Sophia Loren, are incomprehensible to today's intelligentsia, because they embody characteristics mocked by today's culture. Through two-thirds of the movie, Rodrigo and Chimene are in personal war with each other, because they're so alike. They're locked into their codes. When they finally come together shortly before intermission, after a couple wonderful scenes involving a leper, a young girl, and a stable, the moment is powerful.

Wednesday, August 4, 2010

What's Wrong with Film Critics?

Critic Steven Jay Schneider has a book out, 1001 Movies You Must See Before You Die. "El Cid" isn't one of them.

"El Cid" isn't listed in the New York Times Guide to the Best 1,000 Movies Ever Made. It's not in The Greatest Movies Ever by Gail Kinn and Jim Piazza, or the Time Out 1,000 Films to Change Your Life. Critic Leonard Maltin gives "El Cid" three stars out of a possible five.

Take the thousand-plus movies on the various best lists-- "El Cid" provides a better movie experience than any of them. That's not an exaggeration. "El Cid" is better as a pure movie, as well as being a moving and thought-provoking work of art, with incredible relevance to the world we live in now.

What's going on?

Once a critical consensus is reached about a work, the consensus becomes set in stone. Later generations of critics parrot the judgement without thinking about it.

Examine the two "Best Picture" Oscar-winners from 1960 and 1961, the time period of "El Cid." Both "The Apartment" and "West Side Story" are dated, yet remain highly rated. "El Cid" is a better movie than either of them.

What's wrong with film critics?

When criticism becomes disconnected from sense and reality, when it's not able to state or even see the obvious, then it has no usefulness to the art. This is the state of criticism today in arts from literature to movies-- the critics' loyalty isn't to art, isn't to truth, isn't to sense, but instead to themselves and their station.

Tuesday, August 3, 2010

When Movies Peaked

Production values for film reached a peak in 1953 with "The Robe" and the introduction of Cinemascope. Photographic clarity, color (original Technicolor), sets-- the overall photographic look-- had never been better.

From this point through 1963, a time of low inflation, filmmakers had the money to spend on lavish productions. The result was a series of sumptious flicks that were like a series of breathtaking paintings.

As well, the quality of screenwriting remained very high. Many of cinema's greatest directors, such as Alfred Hitchcock, David Lean, John Ford, and George Stevens, were at their peak. Best of all was the movie music of the period. Music is an underrated element of the art of film-- crucial to the highest artistic experience. From 1958 through 1963, in a conjunction of peaking talent, many of the best ever film composers did their greatest work: Miklos Rozsa; Bernard Herrmann; Dimitri Tiomkin; Elmer Bernstein; Jerome Moross; Maurice Jarre; Alex North; and likely a few I'm forgetting.

If film is a combination of artistic elements, especially the visual and the aural, with narrative and character depth added, it's hard to choose a period when the elements better came together. They came together best of all in "El Cid."